The 2012 Farm Bill Will Be Visiting a Lame Duck

Farm from shutterstock.com

Greetings, Farm Bill watchers! Ecocentric’s 2012 Farm Bill coverage began this summer and has followed the legislation through the Senate and House Agricultural Committees. Since the bill was not introduced to the full House of Representatives for a vote prior to the August Congressional recess, we've had to wait to see whether the bill would move forward during this fall’s session from September 10 through October 5.

Well, it’s official. Last Thursday, September 20, Speaker of the House John Boehner confirmed that the House will not vote on the 2012 Farm Bill during this brief Congressional working session and thus we'll zip right past that pesky September 30 expiration date on the former bill. (I'll explain what this means momentarily.)  It’s possible that during Congress' upcoming lame duck session in November, a one-year extension of the current bill will be voted on, and then we'll get to do this all over again next year!

So what happens on October 1, or The Day After the Deadline, you ask? Not much. According to the Congressional Research Service, food stamps, crop insurance and some conservation programs will keep humming anyway. Others will not. It’s important to note that as 2012’s crops are harvested, price supports set by the 2008 bill will still hold. While the funding is allocated per fiscal year, crops' eligibility for that funding is determined as per the calendar year.  We won’t see effects on commodities until the first winter wheat is harvested in 2013 ; if there hasn’t been an extension by then, though, we'll have plenty of other problems on our hands.

That said, immediate impacts could be felt by dairy farmers as (barring a new bill or an extension) the Milk Income Loss Contract dairy safety net would cease, which has been a talking point used by Secretary of Agriculture Tom Vilsack and other politicians out on the stump during August.  One pretty big consequence following that expiration: we'd see milk prices skyrocket at the grocery store. According to the CRS, that likely means “an increase [in prices] of three times as high as currently supported and nearly double recent market prices.” I daresay my fellow yogurt lovers and I would probably feel some pain in the checkout line, too.

There are two other matters, one general and one pragmatic, which will figure in the lame duck session. First, as we've discussed, given the level of Congressional gridlock and political rancor among the parties and houses of Congress, bill passage is a tricky business these days. In fact, when Boehner announced the Farm Bill’s delay, he framed the problem in terms of votes: people who believe there’s not enough reform in the Farm Bill vs. those who think there has been too much. These disagreements are unlikely to yield the 218 votes needed to pass the bill (and raise doubts as to approving an extension).

Secondly, the much ballyhooed “fiscal cliff” will take up much of Congress' time this fall. The ‘fiscal cliff' is the moniker given to the package of federal tax increases and spending cuts scheduled for January 1. The package is contentious because it is feared that it could stifle economic growth, triggering another recession (in big-picture economic terms we haven’t been in one for a couple of years – which is not to say your checkbook and household finances may have tipped you off). Yet “doing nothing” could add to our rather large deficit. The Farm Bill will have to be resolved amidst that larger context.

While not a lot of policy has been implemented, a whole lot of politics has been going on where the bill is concerned, with the Congressional agricultural committees and other legislators representing farmers calling for a vote regardless of these circumstances.

Seasoned farm bill watchers will recall that when the bill was last up for renewal in 2007, we blew past September 30 and made it all the way until December 26 before an extension was passed; that effort begat the 2008 Farm Bill. So we're not in completely unprecedented territory.  Yet.

Responses to "The 2012 Farm Bill Will Be Visiting a Lame Duck"

Leave a Comment

Comments are moderated and generally will be posted if they are on topic. You represent that comments submitted do not infringe upon anyone's rights including copyright, trademark, privacy or other personal or proprietary rights.


We need to make sure you're a human and not a spambot. Please answer the following question. What is 8 + 20 equal to?

By submitting a comment here you grant us a perpetual license to reproduce your words and name/website in attribution.